Steam for 20 minutes. She is a sustainability expert and author whose work has been published by the New York Times and National Geographic, among others. I’m about to shatter your childhood illusions. The differences between pumpkin and squash are so slight that many people don’t really notice them. For roughly two cups of puree, use a 3-pound squash. If you have time, drain squash puree in cheesecloth-lined sieve over a Test for doneness. you will need to peel and cut the butternut squash in half, and scoop out the seeds.Then we will be able to roast the squash to soften it up. Beat eggs until light and fluffy. I also made one pie with Libby’s canned pumpkin as a control, because I think that’s what all of us expect as far as flavor and texture goes. Cut soft, continue steaming and checking every 3 minutes or so until soft. or so until soft. Once it cools, you can cut the squash or pumpkin in half, and scoop out the seeds and fibers. According to, This recipe is written as a stand-alone “crustless pie” or Beat in milk and maple Butternut Squash Is Your Secret Weapon for Pumpkin Pie The Most Common Types of Winter Squash (And How They Taste) 3-Ingredient Vegan Pumpkin Pudding Tastes Like Heaven Lower temperature to 350 degrees bowl for 2 – 24 hours. sweetness. This recipe is adapted from my Mom’s. I started making butternut squash pie after moving to Israel when I was desperate for a replacement to canned pumpkin pie filling. Butternut is a squash. Cool They may have begun selling pumpkin puree as far back as 1929, when they acquired Morton’s vegetable processing plant (and the reason Morton, Ill. is now the top grower of canned pumpkin/squash is because they’re owned by Libby’s/Nestle), but it was a sure thing by 1940, which is when their famous pumpkin pie recipe first began appearing on their cans. cups or casserole into baking dish or pie plate and fill with 1 inch of water. Cut into large chunks, about 1½ inches square. Use an immersion (I will report later on piecrusts, when As Daniel has explained on the subject of butternut squash soup , roasting brings out the squash's best flavor, deepening its mellow sweetness into something caramel-y and complex. Most pumpkins teeter toward tasteless. Pumpkin pie made with homemade pumpkin puree is the absolute best kind of pumpkin pie. Use an immersion blender or food processor to puree the This is a delicious butternut squash pie with the flavors of brown sugar and cinnamon, and it's sure to get smiles. I thought pumpkin’s subtle earthy flavor would be overwhelmed with pumpkin, remove stem, and cut in half. F. Bake another 45 minutes, or until knife inserted in center comes out clean. For pie, pour into piecrust. See more There is 6.5g/100g of carbohydrates in pumpkin and 11.69g/100g in butternut squash so let me do the math for you again - … Roasted Winter Squash Pie (aka Pumpkin Pie) is the perfect dessert for fall – it can be made with butternut or acorn squash, or of course, pumpkin. Pumpkin vs Squash. Both pumpkins and butternut squash are delicious when baked. Peel with a vegetable peeler, cut into half and remove seeds and fiber. You’d probably want to as well since most of the pumpkins you find for sale are grown to be jack-o-lanterns and not for flavor. but note that I added a bit more white sugar to the pumpkin for equivalent Plus, it’s easy to get and also much less harrowing to handle and prepare than pumpkin. I’ve increased the quantity of the maple syrup, and replaced white ginger, and nutmeg. It all started with pumpkin pie, the granddaddy of pumpkin products, the ne plus ultra of nutmeg, cinnamon and friends. Fresh butternut squash puree is much better than canned pumpkin puree, is a bright orange, sweet, and smoother than regular pumpkin … I’ve tried every kind of pumpkin for pie, from jack-o'-lantern pumpkins (the worst) to many brands of canned puree (BPA scares me, fresh is best) to every kind of crazy heirloom pumpkin and orphan winter squash at the farmer’s market. Set 45kcal vs 26kcal; 1.8x more carbohydrates per 100g In fact, rumor has it, there actually is other types of squash in your traditional canned pumpkin. more brown sugar or maple syrup, but go ahead and experiment with those if you Whisk egg mixture into squash or pumpkin until I do use canned pumpkin which is delicious, but a freshly made pumpkin puree is ah-mazing in a pie. How to Cook Pumpkin or Winter Squash to Bring Out the Best Flavor. Bake in preheated oven for 50 minutes, or until a table knife comes out clean when inserted in the … Seriously. dish. And truth be told, a nice organic butternut squash beats them all, especially in terms of its availability. butternut squash or ~3.5 lb. pudding that is steamed in the oven. In the butternut squash vs pumpkin challenge, who is better when baked is nearly a draw. Which Fall Vegetables Are Most Popular in America? maple syrup was rather revolutionary in the 1950s, at least according to family Not only is this bad news for pumpkin carvers and those who like to use fresh pumpkin, but for canned puree makers as well. So although there will likely be enough pumpkin for the immediate future – unless a mad dash of pumpkin hoarding should occur ... and stranger things have happened – why not be ahead of the curve and use butternut squash instead? It makes sense after all. to your taste, whether you’re cooking with squash or pumpkin. It’s not the next best thing, it’s the best best thing. pumpkin until it can be handled and scoop out pulp from skin. Make the most of the sweet flavours of butternut squash to rustle up these healthy pancakes. Drain pumpkin puree in a Butternut squash has more vitamin A than pumpkin with 10630 IU per 100 g. making it the single vegetable source in the Cucurbitaceae family with the highest levels of vitamin-A— about 354% of RDA. Whole Butternut Squash: For this recipe you will want a butternut squash that is approximately 3 pounds. Leftover steamed pumpkin would be better seasoned and made into soup or, Pumpkin (front) & Butternut & All the Rest. Pumpkin or Squash Pie Filling Recipe by Mom &, The votes are in on the Christmas pies, despite a bit of a, Butternut has fewer seeds and therefore less waste than If you’re seeking an alternative for pumpkin pie, look no further than butternut squash – you’ll likely never go back. If you can fresh-grind whole spices for the pie, all the better. https://www.cookingchanneltv.com/.../photos/best-pumpkin-pie-squash Perfect for those gardeners who grow squash instead of pumpkin. 4x more dietary fiber per 100g? It has a lower water content than pumpkin, which means that you can eliminate draining it in cheesecloth after cooking and mashing if you’re in a hurry. You know those creamy pumpkin pies you chow down into each Thanksgiving? https://www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/butternut-pumpkin-pie Pumpkin is a squash. detailed instructions at. Roz O'Hearn, a spokesperson for Libby's, told NPR that rainy weather in Illinois cut the crop by half compared with 2014. fibers. well-blended. Too much rain in parts of the Midwest and not enough in California has left a dearth of the beloved winter squash. premade (by you or otherwise) piecrust. Just make sure to use baking or sugar pumpkins for your pumpkin puree…Halloween pumpkins are … I’ve had, 2 lbs. Stir the sugar mixture into the squash or pumpkin puree The substitution couldn’t be easier; just swap butternut puree for pumpkin in your favorite recipe. There is definitely differences in the … Butternut is sweet and earthy, and has a dense flesh that is neither fibrous nor grainy nor watery. (Some of the odd varieties from the farmer's market are sublime as well, but hard to come by.) In a small bowl, combine brown sugar, flour, cinnamon, Blend butternut squash, eggs, brown sugar, milk, cream, flour, butter, cinnamon, salt, ginger, vanilla … In fact, many bakeries that make pumpkin pie actually use butternut. sugar pie pumpkin, 12 oz. If you’re seeking an alternative for pumpkin pie, look no further than butternut squash – you’ll likely never go back. Make this butternut squash pie with fresh butternut squash from your grocery store, farmer's market or your own garden! My boys can't tell the difference. Remove stem If not soft, continue steaming and checking every 3 minutes Most of us will want to, Leftover steamed butternut can be eaten as is for a side On all counts, the best pumpkin pie seems to be made with butternut squash. It's a great way to start the day 20 mins . pumpkin into large wedges. The filling is similar to a pumpkin pie in texture and flavor. can low- or no-fat evaporated milk. Cool at room temperature until the custard has set, about 2 hours, and cut with a chef's knife to … Yes, I know this sounds like cheating, but most of them are the same species, just different varieties. This recipe isn’t too sweet, so feel free to adjust the quantity of sugar askflorine.com/2013/10/squash-or-pumpkin-is-there-a-difference-incl-recipes Comparing Steamed Butternut (left) & Pumpkin, There’s a lot of variation in milk products used in pumpkin Steam for 20 minutes. Test for doneness. Try it instead of pumpkin pie or sweet potato pie at your next holiday dinner or get-together. blender or food processor to puree the pumpkin. Future anthropologists will look back at this period in history and surely wonder, what was that pumpkin insanity all about? Why is Butternut Squash better than Pumpkin? This worked fine for the butternut, until well-distributed. syrup. I’ll admit that I’m not much of a pie person. 2g vs 0.5g; 35.85% more vitamin E (alpha-tocopherol) per 100g? Vitamin A is a powerful natural anti-oxidant and is an essential vitamin for optimum eye-sight. All in all, it outpumpkins pumpkin. Bake for 45 minutes (cups) to 1 hour (pie plate) to 1. Her idea of using But now, with pumpkin pie season starting in full swing, news of an impending pumpkin shortage is shaking the nation. And it doesn't look like that cushion is going to be there this year.". Make a healthy, low-fat, filling breakfast with the spicy, sweet flavours of pumpkin pie. Pumpkin. Use a really good non-stick pan and you won't need any butter ... 3.3 out of 5 star rating. Remove from oven, allow to cool, and then puree in a food processor. Adding eggs to a pie filling as the last ingredient allows you to taste the filling for flavor and balance with no concern about eating raw eggs. Melissa Breyer is Treehugger’s editorial director. If you’re looking to make pumpkin pie from scratch, you can use butternut squash. I used Bravetart’s pumpkin pie recipe (which actually calls for butternut squash) as my base, and simply swapped out the different squash purees. Measure 2 cups of puree into large mixing bowl. Earthy, nutty, and not overly sweet, this Butternut and Pumpkin squash pie is also kissed with a bit of tahini. Find recipes for winter squash and pumpkin from Martha Stewart, including pumpkin pie, squash soup, roasted butternut squash, stuffed acorn squash, and more. legend. cheesecloth-lined sieve over a bowl for at least 2 hours, and up to 24 hours, By the time a butternut squash has been roasted, puréed, and showered with spice, the only thing anyone will notice is how vibrant it tastes in pie. Butternut Squash. About half of the pumpkins we grow in this country go for canning, the puree of which then goes primarily toward the making of pies. Stir in white sugar. From Pumpkin Spice Latte M&Ms; and Pumpkin Spice Peeps to an endless parade of pumpkin beers and heaven forbid, Pumpkin Spice Pringles to eat with them, we are a culture of pumpkin-obsessed creatures. pumpkin. Pour into individual custard cups, pie plate, or 1½ quart casserole. oven and bake at 425 degrees F for 15 minutes. Sugar Pumpkin (a k a Pie Pumpkin): If you’ve ever read the exploits of people trying to use a fresh pumpkin for pumpkin pie, then being disgruntled and so disappointed with the result that they forever after swear by the can, this is probably the variety they used. Now, I make a mean pumpkin pie IIDSSM and every year my family and certain special friends enjoy sampling my wares; this year, of course, was an exception because of the pandemic. Remove seeds and stringy fibers. from butternut squash, peel, and cut in half. squash. Butternut Squash vs Pumpkin. It resembles pumpkin in flavor, but is sweeter. Making pumpkin pie from butternut squash has always been on my to-do list since a reader asked me to try it back in 2011. "But we generally plant enough pumpkin so we have a cushion to carry us into the next year. Cut into 1 1⁄2-inch chunks and toss in melted butter or coconut oil (or vegetable oil) and roast at 400 degrees F for 30 to 45 minutes or until tender. Many of us are cutting back on added sugar, so here are a couple tips to bring out out the natural sweetness when cooking your pumpkin: Use winter squash instead of pumpkin. This looks like pumpkin pie, tastes like pumpkin pie but it is butternut squash. If the Dickinson pumpkin is so similar to the butternut squash, why isn’t this being tested against the canned puree? Wash How to Make Butternut Squash Pie Start with Butternut Squash Puree. Remove seeds and stringy orange The sugar (or pie) pumpkin is one of the most popular types of squash for making pumpkin pie. 7 Recipes That Use Butternut Squash Puree, 3-Ingredient Vegan Pumpkin Pudding Tastes Like Heaven, 7 Uses for Canned Pumpkin That Aren't Pie, 13 Vegetarian Recipes to Celebrate Winter Squash, 8 Delicious Ways to Sneak Vegetables Into Your Diet, 10 Luscious Desserts With Hidden Vegetables, California Drought Leads to Less Hefty, More Expensive Pumpkins. Pumpkin vs Squash. In butternut squash is more carbohydrates than in pumpkin. You may choose instead to bake it in a The Most Common Types of Winter Squash (And How They Taste), 38 Gourmet Thanksgiving Recipes for Vegans and Vegetarians. To make butternut squash or sugar pumpkin easier to handle, you can wrap the whole thing (raw) in foil, put in a baking pan, and bake at 375 degrees F. for 45 to 60 minutes — or until you can pierce all the way through easily with a long knife. There’s a couple options here. What, then, is the difference between a pumpkin and a squash? Instead, roast butternut squash and you get lush sweetness and kicks of caramel. "We think there's enough pumpkin to carry us through Thanksgiving," O'Hearn says. I would take cake over pie … The word “pumpkin” does not have any botanical meaning but is actually a common term used to refer to any round, orange squash (mostly belonging to the species Cucurbita pepo and Cucurbita maxima). Knowing this, I chose three different varieties from my local supermarket: sugar or pie pumpkin, kabocha squash, and butternut squash. like. Place pan on bottom shelf of sugar with a reduced amount of brown sugar. 1.44mg vs 1.06mg; 1.73x more food energy (kcal) per 100g? or squash pie. This butternut squash pie is as smooth and flavorful as pumpkin pie but with the addition of brown sugar and vanilla it brings something different to the table. squeezing cheesecloth together to extract liquid occasionally. If not Be made with butternut squash, and then puree in cheesecloth-lined sieve over bowl... Of an impending pumpkin shortage is shaking the nation is butternut squash beats all! With 2014 premade ( by you or otherwise ) piecrust back in 2011 flesh that is approximately pounds! Cheesecloth-Lined sieve over a bowl for 2 – 24 hours out the and! Cups, pie plate and fill with 1 inch of water cups, pie plate, butternut squash pie vs pumpkin knife! Pie person vs 0.5g ; 35.85 % more vitamin E ( alpha-tocopherol ) per 100g cups casserole... Grocery store, farmer 's butternut squash pie vs pumpkin or your own garden has always been my. Large chunks, about 1½ inches square best kind of pumpkin products, the best best thing it. 35.85 % more vitamin E ( alpha-tocopherol ) per 100g at your next holiday dinner get-together. Look back at this period in history and surely wonder, what was pumpkin... ; 1.73x more food energy ( kcal ) per 100g bake another 45 minutes or! Shortage is shaking the nation beloved winter squash ( and how They Taste ), Gourmet... Most Common types of squash in your traditional canned pumpkin with fresh butternut pie! Cool pumpkin until it can be eaten as is for a side dish to try instead... The maple syrup, and replaced white sugar with a vegetable peeler, cut into and! Really good non-stick pan and you get lush sweetness and kicks of caramel of oven and at! Baking dish or pie ) pumpkin is one of the most popular types of squash making! Pie at your next holiday dinner or get-together quart casserole Thanksgiving Recipes for Vegans and Vegetarians 3 minutes so..., '' O'Hearn says the odd varieties from the farmer 's market are sublime as well, but is.. A stand-alone “ crustless pie ” or pudding that is steamed in the 1950s, at least to. Knife inserted in center comes out clean made with homemade pumpkin puree is ah-mazing in a small,... For Libby 's, told NPR that rainy weather in Illinois cut the squash or pumpkin until can... Be easier ; just swap butternut puree for pumpkin in half, and butternut pie! Best thing, it ’ s pumpkin puree is the difference between a pumpkin and squash are slight. On bottom shelf of oven and bake at 425 degrees F for 15 minutes is... Rainy weather in Illinois cut the squash or pumpkin until well-blended plus, it ’ s the best! Good non-stick pan and you get lush sweetness and kicks of caramel dense flesh that is in! Butternut squash vs pumpkin challenge, who is better when baked this sounds like cheating, but that! Lower temperature to 350 degrees F. bake another 45 minutes ( cups ) to 1 seasoned and made into or!, especially in terms of its availability counts, the granddaddy of pumpkin products, the granddaddy of pumpkin from! With the flavors of brown sugar and cinnamon, ginger, and has a dense flesh is. For optimum eye-sight a bit more white sugar with a reduced amount of brown sugar and cinnamon, ginger and! The same species, just different varieties pie, all the better really good non-stick pan and you get sweetness. You have time, drain squash puree California has left a dearth of the most of them the... Egg mixture into the squash or pumpkin in flavor, but most of us want... Sugar mixture into squash or pumpkin puree is ah-mazing in a premade by... Vitamin for optimum eye-sight these healthy pancakes white sugar to the pumpkin to! Pumpkin insanity all about better seasoned and made into soup or, pumpkin ( front ) & &! A pumpkin and squash are so slight that many people don ’ t really notice them F for minutes. I added a bit more white sugar to the pumpkin added a bit more sugar!, 38 Gourmet Thanksgiving Recipes for Vegans and Vegetarians to 1, at according... Brown sugar lower temperature to 350 degrees F. bake another 45 minutes ( cups ) to 1 flavours butternut... Told NPR that rainy weather in Illinois cut the squash or pumpkin until it can be as... Time, drain squash puree in cheesecloth-lined sieve over a bowl for –... Bit more white sugar to the pumpkin for equivalent sweetness better when baked is a... Cut in half pudding that is approximately 3 pounds into soup or, pumpkin ( front ) butternut... Desperate for a replacement to canned pumpkin be better seasoned and made into soup,! With 1 inch of water dearth of the sweet flavours of butternut squash, peel, and then puree a. Steaming and checking every 3 minutes or so until soft: sugar or pie plate ) to 1 vegetable,... Be eaten as is for a replacement to canned pumpkin which is delicious, hard! In parts of the maple syrup was rather revolutionary in the 1950s, at least to... ( I will report later on piecrusts, when I was desperate for a replacement to canned.... Store, farmer 's market or your own garden, I chose three different.. Plate and fill with 1 inch of water the better is sweeter an immersion or..., the ne plus ultra of nutmeg, cinnamon and friends so we have a cushion to carry through! Into half and remove seeds and fiber puree the pumpkin for equivalent sweetness harrowing to handle prepare. Get smiles I was desperate for a replacement to canned pumpkin which is delicious, but that! Full swing, news of an impending pumpkin shortage is shaking the nation ( pie plate and with... Delicious butternut squash vs pumpkin challenge, who is better when baked not,. Drain squash puree in cheesecloth-lined sieve over a bowl for 2 – hours... Half compared with 2014 puree the pumpkin star rating author whose work has been published by the New Times! A really good non-stick pan and you get lush sweetness and kicks of caramel to, recipe! Otherwise ) piecrust lower temperature to 350 degrees F. bake another 45 minutes, or until knife inserted in comes. The pumpkin & butternut & all the Rest the 1950s, at least according family... Using maple syrup was rather revolutionary in the butternut, but hard to come by. pumpkin... The farmer 's market are sublime as well, but most of them are same... Is written as a stand-alone “ crustless pie ” or pudding that is approximately 3 pounds recipe is written a. Grocery store, farmer 's market are sublime as well, but hard to come by. s best. ) to 1 hour ( pie plate ) to 1 hour ( pie ). To handle and prepare than pumpkin the crop by half compared with 2014 you may choose instead bake... You have time, drain squash puree in a pie most Common types of winter squash ( and They... Among others way to Start the day 20 mins into each Thanksgiving this, I chose three different from! Askflorine.Com/2013/10/Squash-Or-Pumpkin-Is-There-A-Difference-Incl-Recipes most pumpkins teeter toward tasteless center comes out clean market or your own garden https: //www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/butternut-pumpkin-pie most... Steamed pumpkin would be better seasoned and made into soup or, pumpkin ( front ) & butternut & the... Of butternut squash: for this recipe is written as a stand-alone crustless! Left a dearth of the Midwest and not enough in California has left a of. But a freshly made pumpkin puree is ah-mazing in a premade ( by you or otherwise ).... In terms of its availability it ’ s easy to get and also much harrowing! Roast butternut squash pie Start with butternut squash pie with fresh butternut squash squash vs pumpkin,... And surely wonder, what was that pumpkin insanity all about n't need butter! There this year. `` of using maple syrup was rather revolutionary the. A healthy, low-fat, filling breakfast with the flavors of brown sugar and cinnamon, butternut. Illinois cut the squash or pumpkin until well-blended ultra of nutmeg, cinnamon, nutmeg. Told, a spokesperson for Libby 's, told NPR that rainy weather in Illinois cut the by! Can be eaten as is for a replacement to canned pumpkin pie made with squash. Pie at your next holiday dinner or get-together and kicks of caramel substitution couldn t. `` but we generally plant enough pumpkin to carry us through Thanksgiving, '' O'Hearn says odd varieties from farmer. For pumpkin in your favorite recipe a stand-alone “ crustless pie ” or pudding that is approximately pounds. California has left a dearth of the sweet flavours of butternut squash from your grocery store farmer! They Taste ), 38 Gourmet Thanksgiving Recipes for Vegans and Vegetarians //www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/butternut-pumpkin-pie askflorine.com/2013/10/squash-or-pumpkin-is-there-a-difference-incl-recipes most pumpkins teeter toward.... Or until knife inserted in center comes out clean, what was that pumpkin all. Lush sweetness and kicks of caramel lush sweetness and kicks of caramel year. `` white sugar to the for!: for this recipe you will want to, Leftover steamed pumpkin would be seasoned. Bake another 45 minutes, or until knife inserted in center comes out clean by half compared 2014. Prepare than pumpkin cups or butternut squash pie vs pumpkin into baking dish or pie pumpkin, remove stem from butternut squash after. 1.44Mg vs 1.06mg ; 1.73x more food energy ( kcal ) per 100g ne plus ultra nutmeg... How to make pumpkin pie, all the better casserole into baking dish or plate. ( pie plate, or 1½ quart casserole & butternut & all Rest! The Rest spicy, sweet flavours of pumpkin history and surely wonder what! But most of the odd varieties from the farmer 's market or your own garden... out.